Books on timber framing breathlessly extoll the virtues of huge timbers, while modern timber framing books gloss over the mounting shortage of real timbers and simply lament ‘stick’ building with 2x4s as though it had happened in a vacuum.
But while it may be the case that, once upon a time, when you cleared land for a barn, the trees you took down were all old-growth and ready to support thousands of pounds for a century, that’s simply not the world we live in any more. Stick building is not a choice but an expedient; we build with sticks because the giants are nearly gone.
We’re like the barbarians using marble pediments as foundation or the rubble of statues as infill.